life's like this - avianto's journal

Law existed to protect people. Law created to make people feel safe. But somehow, it worked the other way around in Indonesia. Law was used to shackle people, to keep people on the leash and to shut down the voice of freedom.

The story so far

This was the case of a mother of two children against the all mighty private hospital with divine and majestic name, Omni International Hospital. The mother wrote an email about her dissatisfaction of the hospital treatment to her, which she claimed was bad and horrendously unsatisfactory. The email, naturally, spread around certain mailing list and published on a couple of website including this one (It’s in Indonesian). Reasonable enough since she said the hospital was not really paid attention to her previous complain. Or not.

Update: The English translation of Mrs. Prita’s email are available; credits goes to Ryan Koesuma for translation and Unspun blog for republishing it outside Facebook.

Somehow, the all mighty hospital felt insulted and sued the mother base on defamation/libel. So, they treated patients like cash cows, which unfortunately a common practice in Indonesia’s medical field, and when the patient complained and wrote the complain so the whole world could see, they felt insulted and sued the patient. Well, as if holding up a body of a deceased person because the family could not paid the bill or holding up a newborn baby because the parents could not afford the bill right away were not enough, now the hospital felt insulted when somebody told the world about their misdemeanor and sued that somebody. What was it? A joke? It wasn’t even funny.

What striked me actually, this fiasco probably would not happened, still probably - there were many way to twist the law in Indonesia, if you had the power and money, if one particular law was not exists. Introducing, the famous Information and Electronic Transaction Law aka. UU ITE (Undang-undang Informasi dan Transaksi Elektronik).

Armed with this law, the hospital sued the mother and the court pointed the mother as the suspect and she has been in jail for 3 weeks, as of today (Source: Koran Tempo in Indonesian). The trial will be held on June 4, 2009.

Information and Electronic Transaction Law aka. UU ITE

When this law was signed more or less a year ago, I was cringed. I was afraid, not because I could be punished by this draconian law but because some of the points were obscure, unclear and could be interpreted in some twisted way. I won’t go far to explain the law, use Google and read it yourself. Some items in that law were actually good and fulfill their purpose to protect the people, but those items, especially those parts about “defamation and/or libel” were so draconian and easily manipulated especially to those who got the power and money. Added the corrupt justice system, which again unfortunately a common knowledge in Indonesia, to the mix then we had a recipe to disaster.

I am one of the biggest opponent of this law, as many of my respected colleague, but as you might remember my writing titled “Commander” around last year - it was a different case but it lead into this law being signed, the department who were somehow responsible for the creation of this law was ignorant. Now, to add the absurdity of the current situation, the Director General of that department, Mr. Cahyana who hold the Master of Law degree, told one of the prominent blogger, Enda Nasution that the court actually misinterpreted the law. Where have you been, Sir? Did we said this law could easily misinterpreted more than a year ago? And your department defiantly went into deaf mode and said this law was for the good of the people? The truth, Sir, your department were plain ignorant at that time and now it’s time to feel the wake up slap in your face.

That comment also made me wondered; so if the law was misinterpreted, did it because the law was not clear enough or the court was not smart enough to interpret the law? Or even worse, the law was not clear enough and the court was not smart enough too. Again, the recipe to bigger disaster then.

Cowards

Added insult to the injury was the response of some people related to this case. Some said, it mean everybody, Indonesian especially, should be careful of what they were writing online (email, blogs, tweet, whatever), even if it was the truth. Sounds pathetic, wasn’t it? I called them cowards. When the bush was beaten, they were cowering down under, afraid to speak the truth and even stigmatize those who told the truth.

These people were the reason Indonesia never soar as a great country it supposed to be. These people put a blind eye to the corruption of power those institutions above showed. These people chose, deliberately, to stigmatize the people who brave enough to tell the truth. These people were the traitor to free speech, democracy and humanity.

Critics

So, by writing this, I directly and indirectly criticized the medical institution, justice system, a government department and a bunch of cowards. Will I get sued for defamation and libel? It possible. Even though I am just stating the truth, I am not fabricated any facts, known facts, about the corrupt system of justice, the money seeking practice of medical institution and the ignorance of a government department. So if the worse thing happened then all I can say is the country I always love is going back to the way it used to be, a repressive, totalitarian and draconian one. What a step back and for that I am feeling very sorry…

While waiting for the hammer to fall, these are some call to action links (all in Indonesian):

• Put the banner to free the mother, Mrs. Prita Mulyasari
• Facebook Cause: Support for Mrs. Prita Mulyasari
• Facebook Page: Say No to Omni Tangerang Hospital

Some of you asked me, why given up a good living in Jakarta with managerial position, good salary and good reputation to go to New York with middle position, decent but minimal salary and no reputation? On top of that, why made a move when I already in my 30s and still not married. Well, sometime I also asked myself, why? Career Career-wise, my decision was a step back in career point of view. I was already in managerial position, 8 digits salary (in Rupiah, of course) and had a huge network among multiple disciplines and industries. It was a / Read more …

Things I notice after living and working for around two weeks in New York: On the street and public transportation, English was not the major language. Almost everybody was talking with their own language here; Spanish, Chinese, Japanese, Germans, Polish, Yiddish, Tagalog, Indonesian, Malay, French and others are just a fraction of multi cultural reality in New York. Everybody was jaywalking. I mean EVERYBODY. If you were not jaywalking than you better step aside because New Yorker would push you anyway. iPod and/or iPhone was ubiquitous, in the subway, bus and even the street. Most New Yorker were listening to / Read more …

Last Tuesday was my last day at Carat. I will take another leap of faith to another venture and building a new kind of life. It’s been only a year I worked with Carat but it felt like a long time because there were so many things happened during my time there. Starting a new division was not an easy task and one year was a really short time to get things going really well. I hope what I did was sufficiently enough for that new division to keep rolling without me. After all, it was practically a one man / Read more …

After a meeting with Ministry of Communication and Informatics yesterday night, I am still amazed about how linear, short-sighted, narrow minded and low self-esteem my government is. From the discussion, all of those attributes were coming out one by one and it scared me. A lot. Self-Esteem If I burn the barn just because I can not catch one rat, I believe people will call me stupid, absurd or even idiot. But that was what happened with YouTube case. I don’t know who was behind the idea of blocking YouTube, the Minister said it was coming from the President, just / Read more …

Indonesian are curiously amnesiac. Watching current news in Indonesia proved that interesting fact. There is a certain events happened in the media (television, radio, newspaper and internet) right now. It is about the same topic again and again. Most of the people, related to the topic, talked about goodness, forgiveness and reward. Fair enough, but somehow there were some missing pieces. How about the wickedness, repentance and punishment? Being Human As a human being we need to be able to forgive. If you are a religious person then you must believe that God will forgive anybody as long as they / Read more …

It’s been a month since my last entry… I’ve been very busy with every inch of life could offer me. Doing this and doing that. Working on this and working on that. I was exhausted… Time is moving fast and I was sucked within. The traffic doesn’t really help and the people’s attitude really does not improve the quality of life. Overall, while of course there are other good things here and there, living in Jakarta slowly turn people into drones. I’ll try to write more regularly now. Hopefully soon there are some little change in my life. It will / Read more …

Getting connected is becoming a crucial part in the business field. So naturally, an office must has an internet connection. It is just the way to compete in this information age. For office’s management this could opened a can of worm. Indonesia Specifically In Indonesia, access to internet is quite expensive, unreliable and not quite widespread. Not many people has internet access at home, most of them are accessing internet in the office. Talking about ethics, using internet at the office should be limited to office’s purpose. Now considering the fact that not all of the employee had internet access / Read more …

Last Friday, 28 September 2007, was marked as my 24 months back in Jakarta. It was longer than I expected. I was hoping I will be back travelling around the world sooner and yet, the only place that I’d been abroad within this 24 months was twice visits to Singapore. Well, things was not always working the way we want it, I suppose. Looking Back Contemplating my 24 months here, I’ve got some important things to write about. Some of you probably already know I am now teaching as an adjunct faculty1 at Binus University International and doing a bit / Read more …

Indonesian are very cultural people. I will not argue that, it is a slap fact in the face. My only problem is which culture? Well, admit it, if you are an Indonesian, suddenly being very cultural is not sound so great anymore. Indonesian are proud for their rich cultures. They boasted hundreds of different cultures living under the same roof in harmony… er, sort of harmony. They said each culture enriched the ‘Indonesian culture’, whatever that is. The Truth The truth is not all ‘Indonesian Cultures’ are good. Of course, it also happened to all cultures in the world but / Read more …

Notes: This entry is a summary of my ‘Visual Gaming’ and ‘Game Design and Development’ introduction session. As a part of education process, this one is a Fair use as it may contain a few citation from other books or writings. Feel free to recite, add or even criticize it and use it for your own purpose. Game is a simulation of a simulation. It is a subset of reality. It is created to control the uncontrollable. It is to take a small part of reality and simulated it within the rules created by a common man. In other words: / Read more …

I just re-read my copy of “Understanding Media” by Marshall McLuhan and stumbled upon the Gadget chapter which opened with the discussion about Narcissus. Note: For those who are calling themselves a “media expert” and had not read the book yet, do the world a favor and read it, please? Of course to become a media expert you need more than just one book, right? 1.5 years of formal graduate school sounds reasonable? We’ll talk about it later. Back to topic. I don’t know if this only happened in Indonesia but I know some people who consider themselves as “narcist” / Read more …

I love London. Been there twice in my life and I loved every moment of it. Such a vibrant city and since I always love public transportation (C’mon, it saves me from driving for hours. Driving is killing us, people), I really enjoyed riding the Tube. Sometimes I even took a ride from the farthest station on one side to the farthest station on the other side just for the sake of it. And I love the building, the park (Hyde Park is amazing!), the small alleys (with some ghost stories accompanied many of them) and don’t forget the history / Read more …

Just visited the World Press Photo website and saw the winner and entries for the World Press Photo of the Year. Brilliant photos there. But, those photos made me thinking about the world itself. As you can see it for yourself, most of the photos (not all, remind you) are photos of people in distress, in pain, in sorrow or to be exact most of the photos are disturbing photos about human and human condition. Is this what the world had become? A place of pain and sorrow? No happiness around? The only smiles on most of those photos are / Read more …

I am losing it This website was started as a personal journal and still is, occasionally. It started to loose its charmed, as if it was charming before. I just don’t know where to go right now. Should I keep it just documenting daily life? Or should I just write more entries about my opinion about “life, the universe and everything else™”? Or… I am open for suggestion. Honestly, I’m kinda frustrated right now. Lack of originality and witty pun. Or maybe I should just take another break? / Read more …

Been thinking about writing this for some time. Try to avoid any controversial issue or even flammatory subject, but whatever I have to write my thought about this issue. Fueled by Rani’s post about basically the same issue, now I will try to give my humble opinion about disaster and faith. / Read more …

Following news about the tsunami disaster after effect is a terrible experience. Reading the death toll rising up each day, looking at the horrible photos and watching how difficult is to get the aid to the most needed people. As if that were not enough, there are some disturbing writing, most of them are in Indonesian language, circulating around the web, e-mail and mailing list. Why I called them ‘disturbance’? Because they are more like noises than signals. / Read more …

It’s been more than a week since the disaster, the relief are still pouring in to the needed country. Coming from the most devastated country, Indonesia, I was troubled with the amount of death toll and destruction. The current estimation of the death toll is about 400.000 since there are many places that had not been explored yet. / Read more …