life's like this - avianto's journal

Law existed to protect people. Law created to make people feel safe. But somehow, it worked the other way around in Indonesia. Law was used to shackle people, to keep people on the leash and to shut down the voice of freedom.

The story so far

This was the case of a mother of two children against the all mighty private hospital with divine and majestic name, Omni International Hospital. The mother wrote an email about her dissatisfaction of the hospital treatment to her, which she claimed was bad and horrendously unsatisfactory. The email, naturally, spread around certain mailing list and published on a couple of website including this one (It’s in Indonesian). Reasonable enough since she said the hospital was not really paid attention to her previous complain. Or not.

Update: The English translation of Mrs. Prita’s email are available; credits goes to Ryan Koesuma for translation and Unspun blog for republishing it outside Facebook.

Somehow, the all mighty hospital felt insulted and sued the mother base on defamation/libel. So, they treated patients like cash cows, which unfortunately a common practice in Indonesia’s medical field, and when the patient complained and wrote the complain so the whole world could see, they felt insulted and sued the patient. Well, as if holding up a body of a deceased person because the family could not paid the bill or holding up a newborn baby because the parents could not afford the bill right away were not enough, now the hospital felt insulted when somebody told the world about their misdemeanor and sued that somebody. What was it? A joke? It wasn’t even funny.

What striked me actually, this fiasco probably would not happened, still probably - there were many way to twist the law in Indonesia, if you had the power and money, if one particular law was not exists. Introducing, the famous Information and Electronic Transaction Law aka. UU ITE (Undang-undang Informasi dan Transaksi Elektronik).

Armed with this law, the hospital sued the mother and the court pointed the mother as the suspect and she has been in jail for 3 weeks, as of today (Source: Koran Tempo in Indonesian). The trial will be held on June 4, 2009.

Information and Electronic Transaction Law aka. UU ITE

When this law was signed more or less a year ago, I was cringed. I was afraid, not because I could be punished by this draconian law but because some of the points were obscure, unclear and could be interpreted in some twisted way. I won’t go far to explain the law, use Google and read it yourself. Some items in that law were actually good and fulfill their purpose to protect the people, but those items, especially those parts about “defamation and/or libel” were so draconian and easily manipulated especially to those who got the power and money. Added the corrupt justice system, which again unfortunately a common knowledge in Indonesia, to the mix then we had a recipe to disaster.

I am one of the biggest opponent of this law, as many of my respected colleague, but as you might remember my writing titled “Commander” around last year - it was a different case but it lead into this law being signed, the department who were somehow responsible for the creation of this law was ignorant. Now, to add the absurdity of the current situation, the Director General of that department, Mr. Cahyana who hold the Master of Law degree, told one of the prominent blogger, Enda Nasution that the court actually misinterpreted the law. Where have you been, Sir? Did we said this law could easily misinterpreted more than a year ago? And your department defiantly went into deaf mode and said this law was for the good of the people? The truth, Sir, your department were plain ignorant at that time and now it’s time to feel the wake up slap in your face.

That comment also made me wondered; so if the law was misinterpreted, did it because the law was not clear enough or the court was not smart enough to interpret the law? Or even worse, the law was not clear enough and the court was not smart enough too. Again, the recipe to bigger disaster then.

Cowards

Added insult to the injury was the response of some people related to this case. Some said, it mean everybody, Indonesian especially, should be careful of what they were writing online (email, blogs, tweet, whatever), even if it was the truth. Sounds pathetic, wasn’t it? I called them cowards. When the bush was beaten, they were cowering down under, afraid to speak the truth and even stigmatize those who told the truth.

These people were the reason Indonesia never soar as a great country it supposed to be. These people put a blind eye to the corruption of power those institutions above showed. These people chose, deliberately, to stigmatize the people who brave enough to tell the truth. These people were the traitor to free speech, democracy and humanity.

Critics

So, by writing this, I directly and indirectly criticized the medical institution, justice system, a government department and a bunch of cowards. Will I get sued for defamation and libel? It possible. Even though I am just stating the truth, I am not fabricated any facts, known facts, about the corrupt system of justice, the money seeking practice of medical institution and the ignorance of a government department. So if the worse thing happened then all I can say is the country I always love is going back to the way it used to be, a repressive, totalitarian and draconian one. What a step back and for that I am feeling very sorry…

While waiting for the hammer to fall, these are some call to action links (all in Indonesian):

• Put the banner to free the mother, Mrs. Prita Mulyasari
• Facebook Cause: Support for Mrs. Prita Mulyasari
• Facebook Page: Say No to Omni Tangerang Hospital

After a meeting with Ministry of Communication and Informatics yesterday night, I am still amazed about how linear, short-sighted, narrow minded and low self-esteem my government is. From the discussion, all of those attributes were coming out one by one and it scared me. A lot. Self-Esteem If I burn the barn just because I can not catch one rat, I believe people will call me stupid, absurd or even idiot. But that was what happened with YouTube case. I don’t know who was behind the idea of blocking YouTube, the Minister said it was coming from the President, just / Read more …

Here’s a long and true story… happened on Tuesday, 15 January 2008 from around noon until late night. The locations and events were true. Around lunch time, a rather old citizen mechanic was asked by a car owner to fix and get the owner’s car which was stranded somewhere in a public parking lot. Unfortunately, a miscommunication happened and the mechanic accidentally tried to open another car with the same look just across the street. Guess what happened next… South Jakarta Prosecutor Office (Kantor Kejaksaan Jakarta Selatan, Velbak) The mistaken car park in the South Jakarta Prosecutor office. Before the / Read more …

It’s the time of the year again. End of year. I’d been overwhelmed with Real Life™ lately and the end of year phase was not really helping me to slow down either. So yeah, sorry for the lack of update lately. There were many issues need to be resolved before the new year comes. 2007 Recap For me, 2007 was a decent year. Not too great but not too terrible. Meet dozens new interesting people, some actually played a great deal in my life now. Doing dozens of projects, some of them were great and interesting while the rest could / Read more …

It was a great party! Blogger Party 2007 was a successful and memorable event. Thanks to all of the committee, workers and sponsors and of course, big thanks to all blogger who were there or supporting the event from afar. It was a blast. Words could not expressed how I felt there. Met lots of people, some I already met before, some I knew since ages but never met and some were new. We should do this more often, eh? Blogger’s power For Indonesian blogger, this event was a moment of recognition and acceptance. The Minister of Communication and Information / Read more …

Getting connected is becoming a crucial part in the business field. So naturally, an office must has an internet connection. It is just the way to compete in this information age. For office’s management this could opened a can of worm. Indonesia Specifically In Indonesia, access to internet is quite expensive, unreliable and not quite widespread. Not many people has internet access at home, most of them are accessing internet in the office. Talking about ethics, using internet at the office should be limited to office’s purpose. Now considering the fact that not all of the employee had internet access / Read more …

Last Friday, 28 September 2007, was marked as my 24 months back in Jakarta. It was longer than I expected. I was hoping I will be back travelling around the world sooner and yet, the only place that I’d been abroad within this 24 months was twice visits to Singapore. Well, things was not always working the way we want it, I suppose. Looking Back Contemplating my 24 months here, I’ve got some important things to write about. Some of you probably already know I am now teaching as an adjunct faculty1 at Binus University International and doing a bit / Read more …

Indonesian are very cultural people. I will not argue that, it is a slap fact in the face. My only problem is which culture? Well, admit it, if you are an Indonesian, suddenly being very cultural is not sound so great anymore. Indonesian are proud for their rich cultures. They boasted hundreds of different cultures living under the same roof in harmony… er, sort of harmony. They said each culture enriched the ‘Indonesian culture’, whatever that is. The Truth The truth is not all ‘Indonesian Cultures’ are good. Of course, it also happened to all cultures in the world but / Read more …

Following news about the tsunami disaster after effect is a terrible experience. Reading the death toll rising up each day, looking at the horrible photos and watching how difficult is to get the aid to the most needed people. As if that were not enough, there are some disturbing writing, most of them are in Indonesian language, circulating around the web, e-mail and mailing list. Why I called them ‘disturbance’? Because they are more like noises than signals. / Read more …

It’s been a while since I wrote an entry about Web Standards issue. But since reading Priyadi’s entry about his research on Situs Terbaik competition entries, I think I will write a complimentary entry. (I have to admit that Priyadi’s research is quite amazing, well done pal! - too bad it is in Indonesian language only) What is “Situs Terbaik”? For those non-Indonesian speakers, it literally means “The Best Website”. So it is basically a national competition looking for the best Indonesian website. So, what is the problem? You may recall my old entry about being a judge and read / Read more …

Lots of people asked me about studying abroad. Most of them asked that personally to me because I was an underachiever student when I was taking my bachelor degree, more than 7 years, low GPA and not to mention being labelled “graduated by compassion not by prudence” by one of my teacher (I will remember those words for the rest of my life, Mr. Purwono…). So it was an unbelievable moment when I went abroad to get my Master degree (with partial scholarship) in Germany (right now I am doing my Master thesis research in Ottawa, Ontario, Canada until the / Read more …

As if their spamming action are not bad enough they are now turning themselves into Wikipedia’s vandalizers. As mentioned in Priyadi, Ananda and Jay entries on their weblog those spammer change the lengthy and comprehensive Wikipedia’s article about spamming into one line stupid writing (in Indonesian language too even though the original article is in English and in English Wikipedia, can’t imagine how idiot they could get): wakkk istilah spamming sih sebenarnya masih kacau, blom ada tuh, tapi menurut saya spamming sih ok ok aja demi kemajuan ekonomi ada yang harus dikorbankan, iya kan? free translation: the word spamming is / Read more …

What the?! From Google’s News (Thanks to Priyadi about this sad news). What was the deal with that? What was the motivation? I am not a conspiracy theory buff but it was seems so strange that the bomb blasted in Paris too because what Indonesia and France have in common is that both countries is both are against United Empire of America’s invasion to Iraq. Strange… Anyway, are Indonesian already suffered enough pain lately? This is the major 4th bombing we had (Bali, Marriot, Kuningan and Paris). Stop the violence!. / Read more …

Those three words really work like magic. Who doesn’t want to get rich in a short amount of time? Almost everybody want to be rich. As if the money is the most important thing in the world, well… it is important but is it really the most important? Looks like it tho, for most people and what do you think e-mail spam or scam or fraud is all about? To get rich quick! That’s why! No, of course not you who receive the spam/scam/fraud then believe what they are saying and in the end becoming their victim… And these people / Read more …

Indonesia’s IT scene experienced a couple of interesting events for the last couple of days. The cases of the celebrated IT personas and the reaction. Roy Suryo (as the time of writing this it looks like ‘somebody’ tried to make some editing attempt to eliminate the facts - go figure) is one of the most celebrated IT persona in Indonesia. Credibilty aside, he probably the most celebrated IT persona in Indonesia while we have some people with a lot more credibility like Onno W. Purbo, Budi Rahardjo and a dozen more IT expert who are not under the spotlight of / Read more …

This time Australian Embassy building is the victim =(. Some photos from the site: 1 2 3 4 5 6 - All photos courtesy of detik.com. More “indipendent” photos are here: 1 2 3. Do Indonesian have to suffer more? Here is my personal message for those terrorist: Stop harrassing Indonesian people life! Enough with that terrorism act, we are very very tired with your action. Nothing good will come out from terrorism act like bombing or hostaging, NOTHING. Indonesian people are already suffered enough without this kind of act so stop your action. I really condamned this kind of / Read more …

Today is the 59th years since Indonesia got its independence. Happy Anniversary Indonesia. May your future will be better than the previous 59 years. Still so much things to do, lots of unfinished solution to the biggest problem ever and so many things need to be fixed, somehow. Anyway, I have high hope for your future and I will give my best effort to make you better and be the best country ever. (About the photo, it’s the section about Indonesia in the Hamburg Central Library (Hamburg Stadtbibliothek). The section is quite small tho. Well, at least there ARE / Read more …

… is today. Woke up early. Voted at Hamburg. Went back home. Wished for the best. For the people. For the country. For the future. / Read more …